Self-sufficient?
Updated: Oct 26

I’m alone sitting at my kitchen table eating breakfast. The large, heavy table is crafted from reclaimed barn wood, and I marvel at its grain and the stories it could tell. I’m enjoying a simple breakfast: granola, oats and cold almond milk. I enjoy a piece of toast layered with Italian marmalade. A pot of PG tips tea, imported from the UK, rounds off the simple meal. A complete, self-reliant, independent adult of the human species: an individual. And our culture values the individual. Maturity, individuation, and self-actualization are the goals of our culture. We socialize our children to become independent. Dependence is weakness, and who wants to be weak? Yet perhaps independence is not what it seems.
Jane and I have often used John Bowlby’s attachment theory in our training of foster carers in nonviolent childcare. Bowlby’s ideas give us a clear picture. Emotional bonds of attachment are essential for healthy maturity. Mammalian young depend on others for survival, protection and learning. Secure attachments in early childhood provide a foundation for exploration and development of autonomy. But attachments don’t simply disappear when we become adults. We still seek companionship and emotional connection through our lives. It may be that our independence is undergirded by dependence. Paradoxically, dependence allows independence.
In 1999, philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre wrote Dependent Rational Animals. Much moral philosophy begins with the image of the independent rational, autonomous individual. MacIntyre begins, instead, with human vulnerability and dependence. Practical reasoning, phronesis, depends on education and in relationships of care and cooperation. The autonomous individual tends to overlook the vulnerability of childhood, of illness and disability and aging. Those dependencies spoil the picture of self-sufficiency. MacIntyre suggests that a better picture acknowledges dependence and interconnectedness. And that dependence is not confined to the vulnerable stages of human life but continues when we are healthy and able and apparently self-sufficient.
I return to my breakfast. I consider again the table and what sits on it. My self-sufficiency and independence are dependent on the tree that became the wood, that was worked on by multiple artisans on different continents. I think of the farmers, millers, bakers, delivery workers, truck drivers, supermarket staff who made my breakfast possible. Of my bowl and cup and spoon and knife, and the natural materials transformed through human ingenuity and labor. Of the electricity, water, home I live in, and the clothes I wear. My simple self-sufficient breakfast is made possible by an enormous web of interdependence by literally thousands of people and the superabundance of nature. Most of that dependence is invisible because the relationships function so effectively. I may eat alone but I do not eat self-sufficiently.
Our human dependence reflects a much wider natural phenomenon. Our mammalian bonds and dependence reflect our evolutionary history. All that exists does so in complex ecological relationships. All that exists does so relationally. The most solitary creature depends on conditions beyond itself. St. Paul drew on ancient Greek poetry when he said, “In whom we live and move and have our being.” That saying likely comes from Epimenides, though scholars are not certain. For me, the allusion points to a sacred naturalism that acknowledges the mystery of the interconnectedness of all that exists, the dependence of all upon the divine. Such interconnectedness belies self-sufficiency but is not in conflict with levels of maturity and independent actions. Interdependence is likely a better description.
I finish my breakfast, clear the table and begin my day. The farmers continue to work, the truck drivers to drive, those in retail to labor, the rain to fall, the seeds to grow, the tea leaves to be harvested. My solitude is not independence.
This table of wood,
reclaimed from a barn,
shaped by hands,
given by trees.
Generosity of trees,
bounty of earth,
blessing of hands.
Blessed.
+Ab. Andy


Comments